Residential Property Data Records on Otterbein Ithaca, New Madison, OH

We found 17 addresses on Otterbein Ithaca, New Madison, OH.

993 Otterbein IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $108,000
Living Area 2,800 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1881

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple

APN D81-0-210-28-00-00-40501
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $666
Lot SqFt. 2,985,167

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Dairy Farm
Ownership Type Trust

APN D17-0-210-19-00-00-20200
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $165,171
Lot SqFt. 862,183

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Farm land
Ownership Type Trust

APN D17-0-210-20-00-00-30300
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $84,000
Lot SqFt. 871,244

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Residential Vacant Land
Ownership Type Individual

APN D17-0-210-20-00-00-30600
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $502,500
Lot SqFt. 957,623

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Farm land
Ownership Type Related

APN D17-0-210-29-00-00-10502
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $120,500
Lot SqFt. 2,181,093

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Farm land
Ownership Type Related

APN D17-0-210-29-00-00-10600
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Assessed Value $110,600
Lot SqFt. 1,742,400

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Farm land
Ownership Type Individual

APN D17-0-210-29-00-00-40100
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $51,000
Lot SqFt. 871,984

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Farm land
Ownership Type Corporate

APN D17-0-210-29-00-00-40300
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $916,350
Lot SqFt. 3,205,668

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Farm land
Ownership Type Individual

APN D17-0-210-30-00-00-10100
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Assessed Value $88,220
Lot SqFt. 1,433,429

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Agricultural Vacant Land
Ownership Type Individual

APN D17-0-210-30-00-00-10102
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $58,000
Lot SqFt. 548,856

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Timberland, Forest, Trees
Ownership Type Related

APN G28-0-110-24-00-00-20301
Municipality HARRISON TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Assessed Value $209,360
Lot SqFt. 3,788,413

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Farm land
Ownership Type Corporate

APN G28-0-110-25-00-00-10300
Municipality HARRISON TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $755,000
Lot SqFt. 1,217,894

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Farm land
Ownership Type Related

APN G28-0-110-25-00-00-40100
Municipality HARRISON TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $40,000
Lot SqFt. 2,525,783

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Farm land
Ownership Type Individual

APN D81-0-210-28-00-00-40100
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Assessed Value $7,650
Lot SqFt. 121,968

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Cemetery
Ownership Type Corporate

APN D81-0-210-28-00-00-40500
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $134,000
Lot SqFt. 9,932

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Residential Vacant Land
Ownership Type Related

APN D17-0-210-20-00-00-30800
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Assessed Value $110,410
Lot SqFt. 2,027,021

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Agricultural Vacant Land
Ownership Type Related

APN G28-0-110-24-00-00-20201
Municipality HARRISON TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Investment Properties near on Otterbein Ithaca, New Madison, OH

222 E Wayne StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $113,000
Living Area 985 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN G31-4-110-13-02-03-11900
Municipality HARRISON TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

120 Cherry StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $163,000
Living Area 1,532 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 1
Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN G31-4-110-13-02-02-14300
Subdivision Falknors Addn

School District Tri-Village Local School District

150 Cherry StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $101,000
Living Area 890 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN G31-4-110-13-02-02-15700
Subdivision Falknors Addn

School District Tri-Village Local School District

163 State Route 726New Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $425,000
Living Area 2,304 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1996

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN D17-0-210-32-00-00-20401
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

132 E Washington StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $136,000
Living Area 1,337 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN G31-4-110-13-02-02-12900
Subdivision Putmans Addn

School District Tri-Village Local School District

328 S Main StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $132,000
Living Area 1,032 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 1
Year Built 1940

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN G31-4-110-13-02-01-15100
Municipality HARRISON TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

204 E Washington StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $160,000
Living Area 1,893 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN G31-4-110-13-02-02-12800
Subdivision Putmans Addn

School District Tri-Village Local School District

398 S Main StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $172,000
Living Area 1,348 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1952

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN G31-4-110-13-02-01-15800
Municipality HARRISON TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

115 Anderson StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $237,000
Living Area 1,582 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1964

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN D19-4-210-18-04-01-10600
Subdivision Anderson Sub

School District Tri-Village Local School District

1004 State Route 726New Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $752,000
Living Area 2,820 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 2
Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN D17-0-210-19-00-00-30401
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

681 State Route 726New Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $596,000
Living Area 1,672 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1886

Property Type Farm land
Ownership Type Individual

APN D17-0-210-30-00-00-20100
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

648 State Route 726New Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $172,000
Living Area 1,823 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN D17-0-210-30-00-00-20900
Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

106 Anderson StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $174,000
Living Area 1,294 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1958

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN D19-4-210-18-04-01-12700
Subdivision Anderson Sub

School District Tri-Village Local School District

122 Hickory DrNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $157,000
Living Area 1,053 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1973

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN D19-4-210-18-04-03-12500
Subdivision Twin Oaks 2nd Sub

School District Tri-Village Local School District

120 Summit StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $165,000
Living Area 1,464 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1957

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN G31-4-110-13-02-02-14900
Subdivision Falknors Addn

School District Tri-Village Local School District

319 N Harrison StNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $178,000
Living Area 1,515 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1969

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN D19-4-210-18-04-01-11400
Subdivision Anderson Sub

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Streets Near Otterbein Ithaca, New Madison, OH

Street

Properties

Avg. Beds

Avg. Baths

Avg. Property Value

Avg. Property Size

Last Sale Date

Holtzmuller Rd8531$356,9221,815 Sq.Ft.3/15/2023Main Dr6421$210,7021,251 Sq.Ft.4/14/2025Main St6731$153,7391,852 Sq.Ft.10/23/2024Main St11732$148,1283,363 Sq.Ft.3/13/2025Main St11531$149,0261,906 Sq.Ft.3/14/2025Maple St6131$136,7021,190 Sq.Ft.5/15/2025Richmond Palestine Rd7432$313,7242,404 Sq.Ft.12/12/2024State Route 1216732$276,1253,353 Sq.Ft.1/29/2021State Route 12112932$325,5511,910 Sq.Ft.11/15/2024State Route 7266532$286,7801,813 Sq.Ft.2/5/2025

Additional Questions?

Looking for off-market properties in New Madison, OH?

Traditional methods include networking with contractors, scouting neighborhoods ("driving for dollars"), or purchasing leads from wholesalers can be tedious. PropertyReach streamlines this process with predictive analytics and neighborhood benchmarks, using New Madison, OH property records and MLS failed listings to refine your search. Effortlessly compare properties, access owner contact details, and secure the best off-market deals at the right price.

What is the median home value in New Madison, OH?

The median home value in New Madison, OH is $180,000, with an average home value of $216,528. The average price per square foot for homes in the area is $63.72.

How Can I Find Pre-foreclosures or Distressed Properties in New Madison, OH?

Foreclosures and distressed properties in New Madison, OH can be found through public records, foreclosure notices, and auction announcements from the county clerk or sheriff’s office. PropertyReach streamlines this by aggregating public and MLS data, making it easier to identify distressed properties and connect with owners directly.

Residential Property Data Records on Otterbein Ithaca, New Madison, OH

We found 17 addresses on Otterbein Ithaca, New Madison, OH.

993 Otterbein IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Estimated Value $108,000

Living Area 2,800 SqFt

Beds 2

Baths 1

Year Built 1881

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Multiple

APN D81-0-210-28-00-00-40501

Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $666

Lot SqFt. 2,985,167

Beds N/A

Baths N/A

Year Built N/A

Property Type Dairy Farm

Ownership Type Trust

APN D17-0-210-19-00-00-20200

Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $165,171

Lot SqFt. 862,183

Beds N/A

Baths N/A

Year Built N/A

Property Type Farm land

Ownership Type Trust

APN D17-0-210-20-00-00-30300

Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $84,000

Lot SqFt. 871,244

Beds N/A

Baths N/A

Year Built N/A

Property Type Residential Vacant Land

Ownership Type Individual

APN D17-0-210-20-00-00-30600

Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $502,500

Lot SqFt. 957,623

Beds N/A

Baths N/A

Year Built N/A

Property Type Farm land

Ownership Type Related

APN D17-0-210-29-00-00-10502

Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Purchase Price $120,500

Lot SqFt. 2,181,093

Beds N/A

Baths N/A

Year Built N/A

Property Type Farm land

Ownership Type Related

APN D17-0-210-29-00-00-10600

Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Assessed Value $110,600

Lot SqFt. 1,742,400

Beds N/A

Baths N/A

Year Built N/A

Property Type Farm land

Ownership Type Individual

APN D17-0-210-29-00-00-40100

Municipality BUTLER TWP

School District Tri-Village Local School District

Otterbein-IthacaNew Madison, OH 45346

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A